top of page
Search

Values-Aligned Fundraising for Outdoor and Environmental Education Nonprofits | Vanessa Baker-Rodriguez, Bravely Aligned

5 days ago
4 min read

What a nonprofit consultant tells an executive director when a donor gives less than she asked for, and how Vanessa Baker-Rodriguez raises money without dropping her values.


Anyone who has backpacked knows the moment after a resupply.



Backpacker treking through the rocky mountains.
Backpacker treking through the rocky mountains.

You lift the pack and it is heavier than the one you finished the last leg with. You feel every choice that went into it. What you decided to carry. What you left on the table.


I thought about that moment while Vanessa Baker-Rodriguez was explaining fundraising to me.

Vanessa is a nonprofit consultant and coach. She came up through outdoor education organizations, as a development associate, a coordinator, a manager, and now she helps leaders raise money in line with their values. When I asked where a small program should start, she gave me two packs.


A day pack for the organization just getting going. A newsletter. A spreadsheet to track the gifts and the outreach. One page that says why people should support you. "Please do track it," she said, "but you can start with a spreadsheet."


An expedition pack for the organization managing twenty institutional funders and twenty major donors. Events. A real database. A process for moving people from a first gift to a larger one.

Then she told me about a client carrying something heavier than either.


An executive director asked a donor for $5,000. The donor has real means and has given at a higher level in the past. The donor came back with $2,000.

Vanessa Baker Rodriguez of Bravely Aligned
Vanessa Baker Rodriguez of Bravely Aligned

"It just felt like a gut punch," Vanessa said.


The director asked her what to do with the disappointment. Maybe a little anger, too. You should be giving more. Why won't you?


Vanessa's first answer wasn't a strategy.


"Let's normalize this experience," she said. "We're having a human reaction. We're having some feelings about this. We have to create space for those. Otherwise it's going to seep into the interaction with the donor."


Then she asked the director to step back. "What is the best possible outcome for the donor, for my organization?"


They considered asking the donor directly whether something was going on. Maybe something financial. Maybe the organization wasn't sharing enough of what the giving made possible. It would have fit their values, Vanessa said. Relational and caring.


That isn't where they landed.


"Just say thank you for the gift. Let it be."



A group of outdoor program participants with their hands in the middle. Fundraising is never a solo event!
A group of outdoor program participants with their hands in the middle. Fundraising is never a solo event!

Then they built a menu. This program costs $100,000 a year to run. This other one, $200,000. Over here, a capital project where a million-dollar gift would get them started. They would share it with the donor and ask for feedback, since this is someone who has known the organization a long time. Then, maybe, ask whether a gift toward one of them might be possible.


"It doesn't have any kind of shame coming up for the donor, or discomfort for them," Vanessa said. "Let's elevate to 30,000 feet and reconnect with what the donor hopes to make happen in the community."


Here's the moment that stopped me.


Vanessa started with the director's disappointment. Before the donor. Before the plan. Feelings with nowhere to land, she said, end up in the room with the donor anyway.



Jackie Ostfeld and Scott Shepherd from Episode 16 of Hopeful By Nature.
Jackie Ostfeld and Scott Shepherd from Episode 16 of Hopeful By Nature.

I said something on the recording that I keep turning over: if we're not sticking to our values in hard times, they're not values, they're hobbies. I learned that from Jackie Ostfeld on a prior episode of Hopeful By Nature. A donor giving less than you hoped is a hard time. A small one. A real one. And it is exactly where the values either hold or they don't.


None of this made the discomfort go away, and Vanessa doesn't pretend it should. "Alignment doesn't mean that we won't feel some discomfort," she told me. She compared it to something every outdoor educator knows, stepping a little outside your comfort zone. A board member emailing a friend to ask for a meeting about funding. It's uncomfortable. It's also in line with what that person cares about. "You start a conversation and you never know what's going to unfold."


There's more in the conversation: a value Vanessa calls plums in the icebox, a menu of ways board members can help that comes with appetizers, a main course, and dessert, and why she tells new fundraisers to say out loud that they're new.


But here's a small ask, and it costs nothing.


That board menu has a dessert: call someone to say thank you. Vanessa says one of the most common reasons a first gift never becomes a second is that nobody reports back to the donor. Here's what your gift made possible. Thank you. It has to happen several times, she said, before you ask again.


So pick one person who has supported your work. Call them. Say thank you. Tell them one specific thing their support made possible. Don't ask for anything.


It will take five minutes. It's the dessert.vvvvv


If you’re building that day pack from scratch, I put together a free starter called Fund and Launch Your Outdoor Program. It walks you through writing your program in one sentence, scoring your readiness, drafting the raw material for a grant application, and sending your first in-kind donation request. You can find it here: Fund and Launch Your Outdoor Program.



— Scott


Wildward Institute supports organizations, educators, and parents building meaningful relationships between young people and the outdoors. Learn more at wildwardinstitute.net.


Resources mentioned in this episode: 


Subscribe to Hopeful by Nature to get the next story in your inbox.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page